High-performing insurance agencies are not built by hoping people will rise to the occasion. They are built by defining what excellence looks like and consistently holding the entire team to that standard. Mike Stromsoe explains why unclear or uneven expectations can quietly limit growth, profitability, client experience, and team performance. He shares how recruiting the right people, setting operating standards, and creating an environment where A players can thrive gives agency leaders a stronger foundation for predictable revenue and long-term value.
Key Topics:
- The attract, recruit, interview, and hire framework for building a stronger team
- How to define what an A player actually looks like inside your agency
- Why allowing one underperformer to remain can reset the standard for everyone
- The five things top performers look for beyond compensation: people, purpose, path, personal growth, and paycheck
- How recorded calls, scorecards, and mystery shopping can turn standards into coachable performance
- Where standards should exist across client experience, sales, operational efficiency, and team development
- Why agency leaders need consistent visibility into retention, revenue, profit margin, and revenue per employee
- How benchmarking, continuous improvement, and predictable revenue connect standards to agency valuation
Connect with Mike:
Standards only matter when they are clearly communicated, consistently measured, and reinforced through training and accountability. When every team member understands the level of performance expected of them, leaders can create stronger client experiences, more reliable sales results, greater operational efficiency, and a culture where high performers want to stay and grow. Revisit the standards you have set for your agency, make sure they support where you want the business to go next, and hold everyone, including yourself, accountable to them.
Welcome to the Scale Your Insurance Agency Podcast. This podcast will give you all of the tools to scale your insurance agency and live life on your own terms. Wherever you are today, if you're stuck or well on your way to the success you desire with the right people, processes, and promotions in place, you will be unstoppable. And now I'd like to introduce your host, Mike Stromso.
Mike StromsoeGreetings and welcome to the next episode of the Scale Your Insurance Agency podcast. My name is Mike Stromso, and I want to welcome you. Today we're going to dive in to one of the absolute top items that is preventing independent insurance agency owners from reaching the pinnacle that they are after. And look, I remember and I know and I still do it, we work so very hard every single day, seven days a week, round the clock, doing what we have to do. But if your team is not performing at the levels that they need to perform at, you're pulling them along, possibly not leading them. Today I want to talk about your agency standards has a problem. How to build a team of A players. Because let's face it, the goal of an entrepreneur should be to build a team. And my goal is to be the dumbest guy in the room. I'm looking to build an organization that is full of high performers that excel in their roles and their positions on the team. And I'm proud to say that in UPP, we have that right now. In fact, I had it happen this morning. My new, we call her her title is Chief Capacity Officer or Executive Assistant, did some things on her own through her own initiative that blew me away. And I was so happy when that happened. Because what we did when we onboarded her, we let her know what the operating standards look like. We gave her all of the tools and everything that she needs to operate in that environment. We gave her permission. We showed her the infrastructure. We shared the vision. We shared our impossible goal. We shared how we're going to get there and everything else. And within a couple of days, she's operating at the standard that we saw in the capability of who she was during the interview phase. Now, let me be clear. When we are interviewing people, and if you want to go back to people for just a minute, attract, recruit, interview, and hire. Let me say that again. Attract, recruit, interview, and hire. That is your recruiting system, if you will. You've got to attract the kind of people that have that caliber, that capability onto your team. You attract it by exactly who you are and what you have become. So the goal is to be consistently improving yourself. Yes, it does all start with you. Attract, recruit. And then you've got to move to your recruiting arms. This particular team member is a contract person, so we found her through a contracting service. Fantastic. Attract, recruit, interview. It was the interviewing phase that's the key to term to determine if that person has it or not. And I'm going to get to all the standards in just a minute. Stay with me. Very, very important. Okay. Through the interviewing phase with the questioning, this person quickly revealed who she was, that she had the capability for the standards and everything else that were required to perform at a very high level. And there were other candidates as well, but this one stood out, stood out above all others. In fact, the last two people we've hired, same thing. They both stood out above all others. Now, let me be clear. We know what an A player looks like. In fact, I'm going to share with you our definition of an A player because this in itself sets the standard. It sets the standard for the person that's going to fill a role on your team. So our definition, and this is on our recruiting page, our career page, if you will. Okay. An A player is a highly competent team member who excels in their position and aligns with your company culture. They think outside the box, which is exactly what that team member did. They think outside the box, they reach company goals, and they help your business succeed. They don't need to be micromanaged, they don't drop balls, they tend to overdeliver, and they are great at creating results. And that is exactly what happened with this individual. They created the results. And we tell them we don't micromanage anybody. We expect, we have goals and expectations, goals and expectations, the standards of what we do and why we do it, based on our core values, our core purpose, and our mission. These are the goals and expectations, our standards, our standards for performance in your role on our team. Ladies and gentlemen, that is at the core of it all. Who is that A player? And when you challenge that A player, and I'm challenging every one of you here today, to raise your standards and not to allow anybody else to bring the rest of the organization down because they choose not to operate within the standards that you've set for the agency. Case in point, uh, our UPP members have the ability to exercise an emergency call at any time, unless one of the executive coaches is not available or off the grid or on vacation. But it's seven days a week. Doesn't matter. There's an agency, a high-performing agency, by the way, who has set standards within their agency. A couple of days ago, two emergency calls within a 24-hour period. Not one, two emergency calls within a 24-hour period. Why? Because a team member, while for the first eight months, nine months on the team, was doing well, was fulfilling the standards of the agency. And this particular agency has done a phenomenal job. Phenomenal job of creating a blueprint for operating standards in their agency. Every team member has that blueprint sitting on their desk. They are trained, they are shown, they are shared with the expectations and the standards for operating within that agency. This team member fell below the standards. This team member started making mistakes. This team member did not fulfill the standards, the minimum operating standards for the agency. That team member is no longer with the agency. That's what the two emergency calls were about: to position the agency to properly do what they needed to do to move forward. Because every day, every week, every month that you allow an underperformer to remain on the team that's not meeting the standards, you are setting the precedent for the entire organization. Just know that. It's vitally important. And if you're wondering why you're not achieving your goals, why you're not reaching the destination that you desire for the agency, I will respectfully suggest that there's quite possibly a team member on your team who is not meeting the standards and expectations that you've set for the organization. And if you're the ultimate leader of the organization, it is your duty and your responsibility. You have the ability, the responsibility, and the capability to do something about it. And if you're not, if you're not acting on it, that's your choice. A decision is a choice. To do or not to do is a choice. Make the right choice because you are responsible for every person on your team. Now, I want to share with you a little bit from our incredible agency journey about your standards for your independent insurance agency business. Because it's about sharing with your team not only the future vision for the organization that you've set for it, but sharing with them the standards that you expect they operate within. Because A players, they want that. And they want so much more. And I'm going to share with you the five Ps. Because truly, this is what the best of the best want. The A players. They expect this from you and from your organization. And if you've got people that are operating below the standards, they're not getting these things. One, people. They want a chance to work with a special group of people. That's why it's so vitally important that everybody within the organization is operating at the standards level that you set, and you must not allow anybody to fall below the standards. Number two, purpose. They want the chance to do something great. Do something significant. That's what they want. Give them that opportunity. And it starts with the people around them who want the same thing. Number three, they want a chance to ascend to great heights, to reach higher than they've ever been able to reach before. Are they able to do that within your organization? Three is path. People, purpose, and path. Show them the path. Give them the pathway to reach their goals and beyond. You know, we talk about two pathways in the scaling environment, and we're just sharing this at our recent UPP Grand Mastermind. There's two pathways. There's a pathway that's filled with signals, and there's a pathway that's filled with noise. The pathway that's filled with signals, you can see your goal at the end, and it's illuminated by signals that are on the way. That other pathway that's filled with noise, the noise are things like shiny objects, and they got dust kicking up and everything else. They can't see their goal because it's polluted with noise. Choose the pathway that's full of signals. These team members, the ones that hit your standards, which are going to provide you the results that you're looking for, they want to choose the pathway filled with signals. They want a chance to ascend to great heights. Your people, your purpose, your path. Next, they want number four, personal growth. They want to grow personally. They want to become more. They don't want to remain stagnant. They want, they don't want to remain complacent. They know that casualness results in casualties and they don't want to be that. So number four, they want to grow personally. Help them grow personally. And number five is the paycheck. But I believe in my heart of hearts that 70% of the A players out there, they're not about the paycheck first. And if you think they are, I will challenge you to change your thinking. Because they're about the other four first. Let's get back to the standards for your agency. So the question is does your agency have standards? And if so, great. And now is the time. Now is the time because we're coming up on a brand new year. Now is the time for you to revisit your standards. Are your standards good enough for your 2027 plan? Are they? I would I challenge you to revisit your standards with your entire team. Now, a lot of agencies they have Christmas gatherings to celebrate the holidays and everything else. Good. That's great. It's not bad to build culture and camaraderie, but set a business meeting also to make sure that you revisit your standards, your goals, your view, your vision for the future. We just looked at our calendars this morning. The 17th of December is when we're doing our quarterly planning. Why? Because we have goals. We are going to reach those goals, and we encourage you to do the same thing. So in our agency, we had leadership teams. Very, very fortunate to have a leadership team. And we were mostly on the same page. Not always. It's okay to disagree. That's the strength of a leadership team. We had standards, and it was on people's scorecards. We mystery shopped our team. Yes, we mystery shopped our team. And I encourage you to engage somebody else to possibly mystery shop your team. How about one of your commercial business owners? How about you mystery shop theirs and they mystery shop yours? Say your top five customers. If they have a business and they want to get better, it's not a bad strategy. Why not? We will review in our agency. I'm looking at the standards that we set for our agency. We will review five recorded calls from the previous month. By the way, if you're recording calls, that's a great opportunity. It's a training opportunity. We didn't record our calls to micromanage. We recorded our calls for training purposes. We'll review five recorded calls from the previous month. They'll be graded per our SIA Way standards. That's why we had, that's one of the many reasons we had standards. You'll be rated on a scale of one to five. If you received anything less than a five, the call would be sent with the scorecard, and there will be coaching that will follow. As a reminder, the SIA WA, our standards, was reviewed at our customer service training and our ongoing trainings. And the most recent version is on our intranet, our internal intranet, our operating manual, if you will, which is where our standards also reside. Where's your one place in your agency that everybody can access, 24-7-365, where they can get all of these things and more on their personal path to growing like they never have before? Do you make it available to them? Can you make it available to them? And if you're not, why not? How important is the future of your business? How important is it to exceed your goals? You've heard me talk and possibly talk about Ryan Blair before. For some reason, and I believe this is no accident, Ryan Blair has come across my online space again. And Ryan Blair said, you either find a way or you'll find an excuse. It's your choice. So here was our standards on how we expected our team to handle an inquiry. If you're on the phone, answer the call with a smile. Identify the customer request. Propose a solution for the customer's request. Obtain the client's approval. Make sure that you're on the same page. End the call with is there anything else I can assist you with today? And complete the transaction per the agreement. That was the minimum standard. The other part of the standard that we always encouraged our team to training was to ask for the review or ask for the referral. If you do not ASK, you will not GET. It's really that simple. If you don't ASK, you won't GET. And there's a specific way to do it. So I have in front of me our general list of agency standards of excellence. Agency standards of excellence, yes. Okay. They're designed to set the benchmark for performance in our agency to make sure they're operating with the integrity, efficiency, and a customer service, a customer first approach. They focus on the key areas of the business that we want to excel at to be able to hit or exceed our goals. One is the client experience and service excellence. Client experience. If you think about any top performing company in the world, it's all about the experience. Who delivers exceptional client experiences? Yes, you got it. Exceptional A player teammates. I hope you caught that one right there. That's why you bring in A players because they deliver exceptional client experiences and service excellent through proactive communication, dedicated and excellent response time. And their results is beyond the average or good retention rates. Why? Because people don't want to leave that relationship because they are exceptional. The people on the other end of the communication, whether it be phone, email, text, Zoom, or whatever it is, they know. They know what excellence looks like. And if your customers, and look, I know the soft market is here. I understand people are shopping, and I understand that. And I understand why. Because unfortunately, our industry has become way too commoditized. But you, if you have depth of relationship with a person who exhibits excellence, people aren't going to jump to lead that relationship. And they will stay for a few dollars. And you might be thinking, Mike, I lost a customer last week for 10 bucks. That was just one out of how many? Don't let that one situation demoralize your entire organization because of one event. And if you have a net promoter score evaluation within the organization, phenomenal. Because that's the client satisfaction gauge. So your goal on an NPS score is 70 or higher. And with today's technology, it's not that difficult to get an NPS score engaged within your entire system. The next standard of excellence, okay, we have client experience and service excellence. Okay. The next area where there must be standards are sales and growth performance. And if you have somebody on your team who is in a sales position, a business production position, they must be exhibiting. Growth and performance excellence. I talked to so many agencies way too often that have production people say, tell me about their goals. They'll describe for me their goals, and I'm thinking to myself, that's not a big enough goal, number one. I said, have they hit that goal for all of the last six months consecutively? They'll say about half the time. And I'm thinking to myself, you're kidding me? And then I'll position them and I'll say to them, I'm you're kidding me. Why is that allowed to happen? How many calls are they making a day? How many communications are they making a day? Are they following the sales growth accelerator? Has it been created for them? Are they being held accountable? And yes, all of these things support the standards of excellence in your agency. And if that's not happening, those are your next action items. And by the way, everything that we're talking about today are action items if you're not doing it in your independent insurance agency business. So sales growth, improvement, hitting the goal. What's the rate of acquiring new business? Do you have an agency team? The entire team can see the production log. They know the score. And if you don't, I mean, think about the sports analogy, right? In sports, every sport has a scoreboard. Everybody knows the score at all times. Why? If they didn't have a scoreboard, it would just be a grandiose exercise program. You got to know the score at all times. So does your production, does the production for your agency, is it shown on the scoreboard that everybody can see? That everybody can see. Not the report that you're going to run on the back end whenever you get around to it and you're so bogged down with all these other things you're not getting around to it. So nobody knows the score. So what are they going to do? Put their head in the sand. What's your standards? Is that your standards? Cross-selling rate. Do you ask your team, execute cross-selling opportunities? Your existing book of business is your acre of diamonds, everything you would ever want, right there beneath your feet. In your acre of diamonds. And what about their referral generation? Do you have standards for that in the sales side of your agency business? You should. Number three, operational efficiency. Operational efficiency. When technology does the work of machines, people finally get to do the work of humans. And I'm thinking about an agency that came to the UPB Grandmastermind recently and brought a couple of team members with them. Very smart move, by the way. Why? Because any leader or owner can go back, go to one of our events, and they can go back and say, Oh, I heard about this, heard about this, heard about this, we should do this. And the team members look at them like, you have something going out of your forehead again, right? No. Because that owner or leader is trying to explain to them what they've thought they heard, but they're missing pieces. So they can't fully explain it. Therefore, it does not make complete sense. But when the team member comes to the event and hears it with their own ears, sees it with their own eyes, asks their own questions for their own mind, they get complete clarity. And a confused person does not act, and a person with clarity takes massive action. And that's what you want. This very smart agency owner brought their team member and went back to the agency and promptly created a bot. Yes, they learned how to create a bot with Grok, went back to the agency and created it. And that owner sent me a screenshot. I was so happy. Because they gave them the opportunity for operational efficiency. Operational efficiency includes automated processes, documentation and compliance, cost efficiency, and error-free processing. When machines, when technology does the work of machines, people finally get to do the work of humans. How can you become more efficient? Here's another one for your notes. Operational efficiency, use Ohio. Use Ohio. Only handle it once. How can you get simpler? How can we simplify? How can we eliminate complexity? How can we push it down to the lower levels of operation through operational efficiency? Agency standard number four, team development and culture. The best of the best, the eight players, they want to continually grow personally and professionally. How are you helping them grow? How are you helping them get better all of the time? How are you helping them develop? Your budget, yes, you should have a budget, but your budget should also include training for team members. So, X amount of money for training for team members every single year. Because, like the late great Zig Ziglar said, the only thing worse than training a team member and losing them is keeping a team member and not training them. You've got to train your team. Think about world champion athletes. How often do they train? Yes, every single day. Multiple times a day in some cases. Making sure that you retain your team members. Team members that are in that kind of environment want to grow. They want to flourish. They want to get better. They will stay. And they want to know the score through individual performance reviews as well. That's part of your standards. Next standard in your agency, and this is on you, the owner or leader, but that's you. Financial management and profitability. Financial management and profitability. You must know that score all the time. How often do you look at your PL? How often do you look at your balance sheet? If you're not looking at those documents once a month, you're missing the opportunity. You need to be aware. Your numbers don't lie. What's your current retention percentage, whether you measure by client or by policy? What's your revenue today? What's it in line with your goals? What's it compared year over year? Yes, you need to know those things. I didn't pay much attention to premium. I could care less. Revenue is what I knew. And that is my responsibility. You should have a historical track record for the last five years minimum running. We call it a book of business report within our UPP circles. We have multiple members who know. And what do they know? They also know our organic growth, 21%, organic growth, 33%, organic growth, 37%, organic growth, 41%. Those are real numbers that I just heard last week from one of our UPP members. Because they know the score. Because they're responsible for those agency standards and they share it with their team. What's your revenue per employee? You must know that. What's your profit margin? How many unprofitable seats are there in your agency? Back to budget expense control. That is a responsibility. And claims management. Your loss ratios is your financial responsibility. Standard number six is community impact and reputation. Yes, you must protect your reputation. Standard number seven, innovation and continuous improvement. How open are you if you're a leader to new innovation, new ideas, and everything else that needs to happen within your agency to keep it relevant, to keep it current, including adopting new technologies. When technology does the work of machines, people finally get to do the work of humans. What does your feedback loop look like? Are you open to it? Or is it, oh, this is the way we've always done it. We're gonna keep doing that. I hope not. Because Mark Twain said, if you just sit there, you're gonna get run over and left behind. Don't let that be you. And next, benchmarking. I've got multiple friends in the industry who do a great job with benchmarking for your agency. How do you compare? And you know the real area that benchmarking has to do with? It has to do with predictable income and your evaluation. Predictable income and your evaluation. Because let's face it, you are working your tail off for a reason. What is that reason? Is the day gonna come where they're gonna turn the agency over or sell it? It's one of those two. You want to make sure that you maximize the value of your agency. And the number one driver of that value is predictable revenue. Predictable revenue. And if you take one thing away from this podcast today, write that one down. Predictable revenue. How predictable is your revenue? And if it's not at the level that you want it or you expect it to be, I challenge you today to go back and look at the agency standards that you set for yourself, for your team members, and how accountable are they to those standards. I hope this has helped you today. And if this podcast has helped you today, please share the link to our podcast with somebody else that you care about. It's super simple. Go to scaleyourinsurance agency.com, share that link with them so they too can set the standards that are going to drive the predictable revenue and the valuation that they desire as well. And then you can hold each other accountable as well. Thank you for joining us today. I will see you in the next podcast. And until then, predictable revenue and your agency standards. And make sure that you go back and evaluate every single team member to make sure that they are operating within the standards you set for them. Because if they're not, everybody is watching. Every single person on your team is watching. They're watching everything that they do and everything that you do, and they're listening to everything that they say and everything that you say. And they're watching everything that they don't do and they don't say, and that you don't do and that you don't
SPEAKER_00say.com for all of the details.

